ago. if you being the bad guy and do not give a toss, then just shoot em dead and deal with the bounty and cops trying to kill you. ) You COULD also repeat the Saint Denis thing that I said in Challenge #1 (doing that about 60+ times . As an alternative to stealing the register, you might choose to rob the back room. Almost a thousand fucking dollars, with no way to retaliate as soon as you walk into the alley. Last time I thought I found it I got robbed for $1500 in an alley in ChinatownContents. This Red Dead Redemption 2 Stranger Mission takes place in Saint Denis and this time, you're helping a risque artist escape the city. . join team superantonio!second channel:talking about their FAVOURITE places in rdr2, so let’s switch it up a bit. The second time I just shot the robber but the woman was already killed. Minor Spoiler - in Saint Denis I got robbed in an alleyway, loaded game and they disappeared It started with 2 kids yellow abuse, followed them down the alley, they called me a pervert haha and then I got robbed. 53. For example, the first point you're "supposed" to be able to tackle him is right before he gets on the trolley. Robbed the tailor, now it's locked. Fortunately this did not happen to me but I did get robbed in Saint Denis when some guy is a dark alley said he had a money making venture. They spent some time in. Guess he was a known scumbag and the witnesses didn’t care. denis. Get a tip from an NPC you rescued in a Random Encounter. Was there a while as i was on my phone but the place was empty the whole time. It is situated between Frontier and La Marque. Enter the gunsmith in Saint-Denis and knock on the locked door in the backroom. Time to go do the ol’ $49,500 gold bar glitch to make myself feel better. Found further north, in the arched hallway dead end. -John is the only Gang member arrested in the Bank shootout. • 9 mo. I was exploring Saint Denis a bit in Story Mode, visiting shops and people around the city. I’m beginning to hate Saint Denis as much as John Marston does – As Arthur I got mugged in the alley, suspecting trouble but assuming it would allow some gameplay. . Mob ambush in Saint Denis? I got ambushed by a group of Italian (?) enemies in suits on the north west bridge, by the mansions, in Saint Denis. But I guess that means its randomized. Everyone in the gang knew about the Saint Denis robbery, also Charles is known for being sneaky, the Pinkertons show up to Lakay because of Bill, Bill tells them that he asked a lot of people so it isn’t too far fetched that someone could’ve told the law, your 7th point makes no sense, just because only Arthur. Arthur Morgan. i lost 1500$ Seems I cant get that money back? Whats extremely annoying is that i knew i will be robbed but i was sure I will get a chance to get the money back. Also RDR2: MR. You can tell he's there because, when you get close, a corpse appears on the map at the spot he's supposed to be. Red Dead Redemption 2 is a 2018 action-adventure game developed and…Walk past the gunsmith and go straight to the backroom. His first order of business will be to take you to the security door and open it. Sequence Description: In Saint-Denis, a stranger asks you to follow him, then you will get ambushed. 236 votes, 29 comments. Young guy bumps into Arthur as he is going into the clothing store. His buddy. ago. Yes you can get your money back, although the robbers might not be in the same spot, but definitely will remain in saint-denis, I found them near. I robbed it once and then it allowed me to do it again, but I'm not sure if that's intentional. You will be able to start this mission once you have completed The Battle of Shady Belle mission. Red Dead Redemption 2 > General Discussions > Topic Details. Contents. jmwall24 •. But when I do Saint Denis gunsmith robbery silently, without lawmen on my tail or wanted level, I do get hunted by bounty hunters. It's possible that Micah had made contact with the pinkertons before guarma, but if we believe what milton tells us in chapter 6, then that rules Micah out. I tried to get onto my horse in Saint Denis and accidentally grappled an old lady by the neck. North of New Austin! Outside areas of the map have enough potential for a Third game. SM-W and. In the first game, as you've said, John is left for dead in 1906. I raged like hell when I saw there was no recent save available. Got me for $1330. Red Dead 2 Saint Denis Gunsmith Side Business. Just checked everything in the area twice. Mission Overview []. The BC Prosecution Service has issued an arrest warrant for Lucas Darryl Bradwell who allegedly committed a “bold midday robbery in a busy area of town” on. theblueraven 4 years ago #4. Arthur Gets Robbed In Saint Denis Accompanied By Dutch Arthur With Biscuit Wearing The Legendary Cougar And Wolf Vest Arthur With John , Micah , Otis Miller'. It just doesn't make sense that the gang can't return to a small town in the West because of a ferry heist (which was atleast 6 months ago by that point), but are able to as easily waltz into a big city like Saint Denis on multiple occasions with no hassle after massacring half the police force AND robbing a state bank. its in the china town in saint denis so just dont follow that guy in an alley #5. Micah is at shady belle. Was traveling in Saint Denis and got robbed $1,300 after following a guy into a back alley (I knew I was going to get robbed, but I thought I could fight back), I went back to the spot and they weren’t there, is there anything I can do or not? 262K subscribers in the RDR2 community. RDR2 featured the RDR1 map, RDR3 should feature the RDR2 map if it was to come out!A popular theory in the Red Dead Redemption 2 community is that Dutch van der Linde’s instability and madness worsened severely after the trolley crash in Saint Denis. . And finally; lasso'd his neck & dragged him from Saint Dennis all the way to Valentine. I returned to the scene immediately after, and was unable to locate the muggers in that instance. In this video. Having had enough of this I just shot the pickpocket in the head when he ran away. The Artist's Way is a multi-part side quest available in Red Dead Redemption 2. Denis discussing the illegal poker game. He's in an alley across the street from a butcher shop and a general store. Same. It must take a percentage of what you have on you, lol. Little shit immortal children. Read Dead Redemption 2 retconned the Van Der Linde gang's dissolution. 347. Man Recognizes Arthur from "A Fine Night of Debauchery" [] In Saint Denis, a man will recognize Arthur from the river boat poker game robbery. This happened to me too and I went looking for the culprit, but never saw him again. You can tell he's there because, when you get close, a corpse appears on the map at the spot he's supposed to be. Helgerson will offer a Chelonian Handbill, which the player may choose to accept or reject. They kidnapped Bronte and killed him right after that abs before the bank job. You can get your money back if you chase the guy and catch him and loot him. Went to help a guy, got knocked out from behind. The. I got robbed in Saint Denis. St. For a map of Saint Denis. Someone posted once that they’re in the L-Shaped (a sideways L) building above the last ‘S’ in Saint Denis on your map. There was this dude who said something about money and asked me to follow him to this dark alley. If you catch them in time you can kill them and get your money back. Red Dead Online Map. Denis compared to the creepy nighttime. Head to Saint Denis to meet up with Samson. If he was showing up on your map, or radar, but you couldn't find him then try these 2 things: 1 - check that he's on the same level as you. Story []. When close enough, press F to tackle. I then proceeded to unholster my pistol, when the boy takes aim and fires a carbine over my shoulder. got robbed in Saint Denis. Required fields are marked. If you don’t know how to open the locked metal door and rob. The only people I've ever gotten revenge on is the creepy ass hillbilly brother and sister who knock you out in their house. Group: Chapter 4 - Saint Denis. but no. I assumed it was one of the mugging. advertisement. There’s actually three different alley mugging encounters in Saint Denis. 3. All because I tried to get on my horse. Sequence Description: This RDR2 Chance Encounter is triggered after you save a stranger from a trap or a. I followed him and got knocked out and robbed. I made a save before speaking to the guy in the alley, because he looked suspicious. CryptoTrains. Just got robbed in Saint Denis in front of Jade Dragon Restaurant . Asking for HelpThanks For Watching!Social Links Patreon:Facebook:Instagram: to cover your face with bandana before you enter the store. It appears that there are at least 4 of these types of events. The mystery of the Saint Denis vampire certainly fits into that category. Got knocked out in the alley and lost $1200. Bro there’s literally kidnappers, slave catchers, murdered civil war soldiers, incest, rape, serial killers, natives being slaughtered, beastiality, assassination, mutilation, man made mutants, torture, Micah shooting a young girl in the face, torturing mentally ill children, I think an implication of pedophilia, and the ability to rip someone’s guts out with an axe or burn. 0:00 / 4:28. Robbing trains is one of the most fun robberies that can be accomplished in Red Dead Redemption 2, and one of the most profitable as well. Robbed in Saint Denis So some guy offered me a chance to get some quick money and then knocked me out in an alley. Saint Denis Gunsmith Robbery Not Marked As FInished. Micah is with them, but he’s stood off to the side facing away from them all. I think a 2nd robbery is a glitch. Ok, they know that was me doing this robbery, I paid my $9. I’m beginning to hate Saint Denis as much as John Marston does – As Arthur I got mugged in the alley, suspecting trouble but assuming it. It’s fun to instigate a fight then watch. Was riding on my horse when this guy who stood infront of an alley called me and said I could earn some money with him. You can kill children in RDR2, or at least one of them. As soon as you reach the Guiteau Square, matchmaking will begin. Here's every single random encounter you can have in the city. . I was riding towards the post office and a guy offered me some way to get quick money. Pick a RDR1 character and a RDR2 character you’d want to see interact with each other. 100 dollar rough profit after it all said and done. Ambush in Saint Denis. Dynamite arrow into the nutsack. If you are in Saint Denis, and someone wants to give you some jobs, shoot them. This mission is for 2-4 players, and you can initiate matchmaking by going to visit Samson Finch in Saint Denis. Posted November 21, 2019. Although the robbery starts off well, Pinkertons quickly arrive on the scene. The player can aim a weapon at an NPC and demand money. You have to. i. I’ll head straight back if there is a chance of finding them though! I went immediately back and there was only a woman and man up on the balcony to the left when you go down the alley. Back Alley. Red Dead Redemption 2 on PS4 and Xbox One has a metric ton of memorable missions. Denis discussing the illegal poker game. . This would mean that Micah was always a rat, but I think there's one event that he wasn't responsible for: the botched Saint Denis bank robbery. About a random event in Saint Denis. Scrawling #1: In the alley, north of the post office. Helping the camp recover from the events of the failed Blackwater robbery, he voices opposition to Dutch's plan to rob the. So some guy offered me a chance to get some quick money and then knocked me out in an alley. Instead, I got knocked out from behind, and woke up in the saint denis grave yard $1,200 poorer. I'm on my 3rd playthrough and still can't find this event that triggers this entry. Arthur arrives at a small church where Brother Dorkins and Sister Calderón are teaching some. 0. Train drops you on the wrong side, your horse might get run over (look just shoot your own horse before riding in to quicken the inevitable) Saint Denniss. . Figured it would be a robbery that I could fight back against like the other ones so I played along, but nope. Okay - So a while ago I did the mission where you rob the Gunsmith in Saint Denis, discovering illegal poker business happening. It is found in the hall behind the grass. 445K subscribers in the reddeadredemption2 community. Obviously that's not supposed to happen/is some kind of bug or glitch. Bronte has the police in his back f. $15000 gone like that, but YOU CAN GET IT BACK!!Why the Saint Denis bank robbery wasn't the result of a rat (for anyone still confused) r/reddeadredemption • John is acting a bit weird, just wanna ask why. Superjaybo64 · 8/11/2021. Same thing had happened once in valentine, and that went well, so I wasn't to concerned. 3. Dunno why I thought he said barber when posting the reply. ago. We as outlaws would never be able to integrate in the city life and avoid the place as hard as possible. 2yrs later, but fwiw, I encountered the vampire as Arthur before finding all the writings as John. . It's supposed to be the worst because it's the city of the future where outlaws aren't wanted and you can't get away with shit there. r/reddeadredemption. It’s not. I'm just glad I immediately made a save knowing it's either a trap or a dishonorable deed. 7k more. I chased em down, looted my money back, boom headshot to me, I'm dead. 0. join team superantonio!second channel:talking about their FAVOURITE places in rdr2, so let’s switch it up a bit. 5yearoldrexrex111. Top. ago. Players can hear Dutch complaining about his head injury several times during the remainder of the robbery, and his temper significantly worsens as the game progresses. With good rail, road, and river connections for sugar, cotton, and other commodities trading, and a new electric power plant, business is booming. Arthur meets Dutch and Lenny in an alley across from the trolley station. Really though, I followed some guy into an alley expecting to be robbed, but I didn't expect to be knocked out by someone around a…20 minutes after I accidentally bump into someone in Saint-Denis Market. In order to fund their escape overseas and retirement from the life of crime, the gang prepare for one last job: robbing Lemoyne National Bank in. Themightyred92 Jan 13, 2020 @ 10:25am. So couple of days ago I did the Saint Denis Robbery Tip for the gunsmith. To rob a train, players. Got knocked out in the alley and lost $1200. My plan was to rob him but then i got hit in the back by a bat and they robbed me instead i lost 990 out of my 3000$ R. I decided to free him to try to re-lasso him and deag him from my horse- this was outside of town- of course the damn st denis police miraculously showed up and screwed everything up. Once in the alley, Arthur will be ambushed. One by the Chinese gunsmith, one by the general store, and one north of the trapper. Hey, it's Ray! Links to highlights found below - First time playthrough of Red Dead Redemption 2 continues on with episode 6!I was at the barber, walked out and at the entrance to the alleyway there were 2 kids with bear talking some shit, I scared them, they ran into alleyway. $15000 gone like that, but YOU CAN. 3. Here's every single random encounter you can have in the city. Any time while in Saint Denis, Arthur can be ambushed in an alley if he follows the marked man. Suddenly, a random event blipped on my minimap, so I went and check it out. /r/RedDeadRedemption - A subreddit dedicated to Red Dead Redemption & Red Dead Redemption 2, developed by Rockstar Games, the creators behind the Grand Theft Auto series. r/RDR2 • Leaked footage of me in saint denis after exterminating the whole of strawberry. Follow Lenny through an. I just realized that the suit john wears in the bank robbery of Saint denis is the elegant suit from read dead 1Go to RDR2 r/RDR2. did this happen to anyone else?Music/Song from Red Dead Redemption 2 - Banking, The Old American Art | Saint Denis Bank Robbery Heist full extended version mission theme (recorded in the g. Arthur will take part in bank robberies as part of the game's story, but, if players are feeling brave enough then they can also rob banks by themselves. Must Be Dishonorable To Trigger The Mission. Scared Horse. ago. Here's how to get it back: Go back to where you. Lol dang! Thanks for the heads up! Huh. He's in an alley across the street from a butcher shop and a general store. 1/4 of your total money gets stolen, if you go back you can kill the thieves and retrieve it. Go to RDR2 r/RDR2 • by Calusea. So I killed the guy in the basement, put on my mask and robbed the register. Red Dead Redemption 2in Saint Denis -- Any way to get my money back? Question I followed a guy into an alley late at night to make some "quick money", knowing I was going to get jumped. Yes, killed me my first attempt, he’ll be back in a day or two. The Saint Denis Bartender Has A DARK & CREEPY Secret You Don't Know About In Red Dead Redemption 2! Cheap GTA 5 Shark Cards & More Games: She somehow slips away completely unharmed while Hosea gets caught. Go back to the same exact spot as quickly as possible, if too much time passes they’re gone forever. It is found in the hall behind the grass. by cheekyuser. Prerequisite: None. It’s not possible to recover your money from the first two. IF. For the first graffiti, get to the saloon in Saint Denis. FancyGiraffe69. You can go back to the general area later and there's an encounter where Arthur recognises the guy that stole from him. I believe I remember someone saying the alley is near the gunsmith Reply. r/reddeadredemption. One by the Chinese gunsmith, one by the general store, and one north of. When you get knocked out, they're gone. Eminem Jan 13, 2020 @ 2:09pm. It's pretty. 0. Around the south-east quarter of Saint Denis,. Ran into those fellows again and declined. 0. Just got robbed $1400 in Saint Denis. There was this dude who said something about money and asked me to follow him to this dark alley. Hi all, I just booked a semi-surprise trip to New Orleans for my husband. SwordCzar 4 years ago #1. All I had to do was go back and complete it. Must Be Dishonorable To Trigger The Mission. . 1. I have dyslexia so to practice my writing I started a video game dairy. What’s your LEAST favourite place in rdr2? 297. The second one they'll offer you goods for cheap (on the street right above the S in Denis) and you'll lose everything. If you get robbed, you'll know by you going through a doorway or brushing by someone and then all of a sudden you see a decent loss of $ on your screen popup. Banking, the Old American Art, mission walkthrough and hints. Red Dead Redemption 2second robbery occurs in the city of Saint-Denis. SirDiego • 5 yr. After having been robbed like 4 times when I entered various stores in Saint Denis in my first play through it happened a fifth time now. Whilst looking for a vampire in Saint Denis, the hero needs to pass through an archway that has the. A Train Robbery in Red Dead Redemption 2 is similar to coach robberies. I assumed it was one of the mugging. HOW TO AVOID LOSING ALL OF YOUR MONEY IN SAINT DENIS!! - Red Dead Redemption 2 Tips & TricksRight guys, welcome back to Red Dead Redemption 2. 2023-05-14. Another way is to Manually Delete every file and folder associated with RDR2 completely - as in ERASE the entire game from your Machine - then re-install the game. Just to the right of this entrance is a metal gate. don't forget the gold nugget on the desk. Map description Saint Denis, the "Jewel of Lemoyne," is a major city and the state capital of Lemoyne. His positioning around Shady Belle are just within lassoing/dynamite distance. Then some dude behind me bonked me on the head and then I woke up in the graveyard with about 300-400 bucks missing. Based on my thoughts, its probably up from $400 000, considering the fact that the bank possibly owns a lot of property, there's a sizable upper crust, lots of poor people, a good chunk of average wealthed folks, mortgages, loans and it. This is a nice. In order for this mission to appear on your map, you must be a dishonorable player while online. One they are offering you quick cash (by the vampire's alley) and you will lose about 25% of your money. lost $1,000 and my last save was when my game was in 30% and i’m on 44% when it happened. m. . Hiply • 6 mo. -John is the only Gang member arrested in the Bank shootout. To track down the vampire, you’ve got to find five different graffiti spots around the big city of Saint Denis. It takes at least twice as long to play the damn game because I have to stop all the time to set up shots. He tried to convince her that the best way to get back at Dutch was to indeed tell the Pinkertons regarding information about the Saint Denis bank heist. To begin the Banks Don't Rob Themselves. The guy asked me to follow him into a alley and i assumed it was a robbery. Urban Pleasures is a mission in Red Dead Redemption 2. Shops are closed at night so it could be that. My plan was to rob him but then i got hit in the back by a bat and they robbed me instead i lost 990 out of my 3000$ R. A Train Robbery in Red Dead Redemption 2 is similar to coach robberies. One by the Chinese gunsmith, one by the general store, and one north of the trapper. C. Bronte knew the gang was one of criminals, and he had already set them up with the train station robbery. The man himself. Wait For Hosea’s Signal; 4 Rob The Bank. How is Rdr2 on series x compared to series s without a 4k TV? 2 posts, 9/12 6:16PM. (Not that the game has any of those !)Ok, I opened rdr and tried to rob it, I entered the gunsmith already with the mask on, tried opening the door and threatened the gunsmith to open it, once inside I tied the door's guard with the lasso without making him shoot and knocked the shopkeeper, then I entered the poker room at the third floor and tied the guard, lastly I proceeded to threaten the first. SWOL, a Twitch streamer who plays a lot of Red Dead Online and Red Dead Redemption 2, attempted the impossible in the Saint Denis robbery. So as you lot can guess I’ve just been tricked into “making some quick cash” which lead me to being knocked out and robbed of around £1400, now I’ve heard people say once you get robbed by these guys you’re fxcked but then others say they’ve found the robbers around Saint Denis, does anyone actually know because I’m on a manhunt for these guys, (I literally was on my way to get. ChrisGR17 · 3/3/2020. I need to kill them now!!! No, where they rob you, every time I've been mugged I just go back to where they mugged me and they're there to kill and take your. After completing the Revenge is a Dish Best Eaten mission, return to your camp and, together with Dutch and Hosea, prepare for a bank robbery in Saint Denis. Chased the guy and shot him in front of a lot of people looted him and got. I have tried robbing gunsmiths, Doctor, and grocery side businesses a 2nd time on multiple play throughs with no joy. The bank robbery in Saint Denis was a disaster. Sequence Description: This RDR2 Chance Encounter is triggered after you save a stranger from a trap or a snake. i got a worse one for ya. after i sold some itens including a 300$ gold bar on a store in saint denis, i made my way to the gun store to make some engravings, next to the gun store an randon event hapenned, a guy in red called me offering a way to get easy money, i knew it would be an attempt of robery but i thought i would be able. He/him. Just lost $1200. You crash, but luckily you’re all mostly okay, but there are still lawmen on your tail. Until you get back all the way to Vanilla - and determine if it's working or not - you won't know if a Mod has broken your game or not. There’s actually three different alley mugging encounters in Saint Denis. Whoever developed the lighting needs to get some medals. 124 comments. Red Dead Redemption 2 Saint Denis Robbed in An Alleyway. Saint Denis is located in the lower right (southeast) of Red Dead 2's map. Robbed in Saint Denis. Red Dead Redemption 2. So I just reloaded it. Advertisement Coins. Head slightly to the northeast of the shop to enter a courtyard with a tree. Graffiti #4: There’s another piece of. One they are offering you quick cash (by the vampire's alley) and you will lose about 25% of your money. RDR2 : Tries to be realistic. I also assumed it would let me fight back. First time I encountered this after 4 playthroughs. He lead me down an alley way and then I was knocked unconscious by one of his mates. Helgerson will offer a Chelonian Handbill, which the player may choose to accept or reject. Man, this is pretty. Here’s where all the vampire graffiti locations are: Graffiti #1:. Get a tip from an NPC you rescued in a Random Encounter. You will find this robbery in Red Dead Redemption 2 at the Rhodes Bank. I think this is the purpose. So about 2 or 3 weeks ago I went around and found the 5 clues for the vampire and drew the little pentagram map in my journal, but I literally can't get him to spawn. 17 comments. During this event, Arthur's horse will be spooked by a dead horse left by the Night Folk Gang. I felt this game definitely set a new standard in lighting. I GOT ROBBED OF $600 BY A PERSON IN SAINT DENNIS. I even killed poor doc. You tackle him as he comes out from behind the chimney if you run around the other way on the roof. Join. Just started chapter 4 and the kids in the back alley,crashes everytime here, five times in a row, can't progress, what to do? Really pissed off. Red Dead Redemption Red Dead Open world Action-adventure game Third-person shooter Gaming Shooter game. Ever since my first playthrough I now walk into every Saint Denis store with my lasso out so when that dude bumps me I can go dead eye and just yank his ass back inside REAL quick lol that town is the worst. This shop is hiding a side-activity. I made a save before speaking to the guy in the alley, because he looked suspicious. The one in the alley in the little China town area in Saint Denis. Red Dead Redemption 2. Once though, he broke free of the ropes, but I had already taken his dagger so he just awkwardly walked around while making the same grunting noises he made while hogtied. It takes at least twice as long to play the damn game because I have to stop all the time to set up shots. Lost a little honor but said hey to a bunch of people on my way to pay off my bounty. Was there really a rat during the Saint Denis bank robbery In chapter 4? Many people think that the pinkertons responded so fast to the gang robbing The Saint Denis bank because there was a rat constantly giving the pinkertons information on the gangs whereabouts. There was $150 000 (approximately 4,5 million) on the ferry at Blackwater which likely came from Saint Denis. Red Dead Redemption 2 > General Discussions > Topic Details. So as you lot can guess I’ve just been tricked into “making some quick cash” which lead me to being knocked out and robbed of around £1400, now I’ve heard people say once you get robbed by these guys you’re fxcked but then others say they’ve found the robbers around Saint Denis, does anyone actually know because I’m on a manhunt for these guys, (I. I've tried investigating the back room like you should. Edited January 28, 2021 by GroveStGTAV. Robbed in saint denis, lost $800 and no way to get it back. When I looted him I did not only get my 330$ back, but he had an additional 660$ on him. SentenceAcademic5767 • 8 mo. If you get robbed by the kids you get to meet them again and repossess it though. Train Robbery. so it. i lost 1500$. Then go across the street when prompted. Saint Denis gun shop robbery done without alerting the po po, fun little side job wish I could rob these side business all day such a great addition to the g. Knock on it and this will unlock the option to rob the Saint Denis gunsmith side business. Last night as I was trotting happily along through a wooded path near Wallace Station, a young boy asked me for help. Figured it would be a robbery that I could fight back against like the other ones so I played along, but nope. To encounter a secret vampire, first find the five hidden messages written on the walls in Saint Denis. I had the opposite reaction—after getting robbed, it made me love the game even more. You can come across dialogue between Hosea and John, talking about the idea of leaving the gang to raise Jack and keep Abigail safe. This one, from what I've read, will often be there when you go back, so you might get your money back. Dickens_Sider • 2 yr. Complete within 5 minutes 30 seconds. Red Dead Redemption 2. Try to press aim button fast. Graffiti #2: Walk east down the street and stand just outside the arched entrance which leads to the trapper. He and Arthur talk about the city. .